IRAs: Traditional or Roth

Posted on October 26th, 2009 in Newsletter Articles, Retirement Planning, Taxes by wayne

Is it better to contribute to a traditional, deductible IRA or to a Roth IRA?  As with most personal finance questions, the answer is “it depends.” Let’s look at some guidelines to help you decide.

With a traditional IRA, contributions can only be made if you are under 70½ years old and you and/or your spouse have earned income. The maximum contribution is the lesser of $5,000 ($6,000 if over age 50) or the total amount that you and/or your spouse earned.  If you have a qualified retirement plan, the full amount can only be contributed if your Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) is no more than $55,000 as a single tax payer or $89,000 as a joint filer.

With a Roth IRA, your Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) must be less than $105,000 as a single filer or $166,000 as a joint tax filer plus you and/or your spouse must have earned income.  Like a traditional IRA, the maximum contribution is the lesser of $5,000 ($6,000 if you are over age 50) or the total amount that you and/or your spouse earned. If deductible IRA contributions are made, the amount that can be contributed to a Roth IRA is further reduced by the amount contributed to a deductible IRA.

The decision on which IRA to use is sometimes obvious:

  1. A single filer with an AGI over $105,000 or a joint filer with an AGI over $166,000 who is not covered by a retirement plan can only fund an IRA.
  2. If covered by a company retirement plan with a MAGI of over $89,000 but less than $166,000 as a joint filer or over $55,000 but less than $105,000 as a single filer, only a Roth IRA can be fully funded.
  3. If you reach 70 ½ and have earned income, only a Roth IRA can be funded.
  4. When saving to buy a first home, only with a Roth IRA can up to $10,000 of growth and income plus all contributions be withdrawn, tax and penalty free.

The following are more subtle advantages of Roth IRA plans:

  1. For those under 40, the tax free growth combined with the tax free withdrawal of the funds (after age 59½), typically make the Roth IRA a better investment.
  2. If funds are required before reaching age 59½, a Roth IRA allows the withdrawal of all contributions, with no taxes or penalty on this withdrawal.
  3. For older individuals, a Roth IRA is an excellent way to pass funds to younger generations. The younger recipient may allow these funds to continue to grow tax free by withdrawing inherited Roth funds tax free over their lifetime

When none of the above apply, the decision of funding a Roth IRA or a traditional, deductible IRA must be made by analyzing your current tax bracket, what you believe will be your future (retirement years) tax bracket and whether you expect to consume the retirement funds or pass them to future generations.  If you need help making this decision, consult with your financial planner or tax adviser.

IRA to Roth IRA Conversions in 2010

Posted on October 26th, 2009 in Newsletter Articles, Retirement Planning, Taxes by wayne

In 2006, the Pension Protection Act was signed into law.  A key provision of that act was the elimination of the $100,000 earnings ceiling for an IRA to Roth IRA conversion.  Until now, only taxpayers with an Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) of $100,000 or less have been allowed to convert funds from their IRA accounts into a Roth IRA account.  However, thanks to this 2006 legislation, on January 1, 2010, anyone may transfer funds from an IRA account to a Roth IRA, regardless of income.

When IRA funds are converted to a Roth IRA, taxes must be paid on the amount of (pre-tax) IRA contributions that are converted.  However, another “gift” from the Pension Protection Act of 2006 is the ability to delay this tax liability on funds converted in 2010.

In 2010, if you convert $100,000 of taxable assets from your IRA to your Roth IRA, you may choose to pay taxes on an additional $100,000 of income for tax year 2010.  However, you also have the option of paying no additional income taxes on the converted amount in 2010.  Instead, you may pay income taxes on ½ ($50,000) of the income in tax year 2011 and on ½ in tax year 2012.

After 2010, you may continue to convert IRA funds to Roth IRA funds, regardless of income.  However, from 2011 on, taxes on the converted taxable amount must be paid in the tax year during which the conversion is made.

Are there any reasons to not use the three year option for a 2010 Roth conversion?   An obvious reason would be if you have very little income in 2010 and expect significantly more income in 2011 and 2012.  A less obvious reason may be the possibility of future federal income tax increases.

The current administration has proclaimed that it will raise taxes on the “rich,” which it defines as couples with incomes of $250k or more.  One way this will be accomplished is by allowing the current “tax cuts” to expire at the end of 2010.  When these tax cuts expire, income taxes on all income level will rise in 2011 and beyond.

Since 2010 is an election year, congress may not be anxious to pass additional tax increases in 2010.  However, with our enormous and increasing budget deficit, a tax increase in 2011 appears likely. Depending upon your expected income in 2010 – 2012, you could pay less in taxes on your IRA to Roth IRA conversion by declaring the full amount of income in 2010, especially if income taxes increase dramatically in 2011 and beyond.

If you are considering retirement in the near future, it may be beneficial to retire at the end of 2010.  This could allow you to convert a substantial amount of IRA savings into a Roth IRA.  With the three year option, the Roth conversions would be taxed in 2011 and 2012, when work related income has ceased.  This approach could minimize the amount of taxes owed on the Roth IRA conversion.

Do not do an IRA to Roth IRA conversions without having enough funds, outside of the IRA, to pay the taxes owed.  If the taxes are taken out of the IRA, advantages of a Roth conversion will be substantially lost.  When IRA funds are used to pay the taxes owed on the conversion: 1) taxes are paid on funds being used to pay taxes 2) If you are under 59 ½, a 10% penalty will be assessed on IRA funds that are used to pay taxes and 3) the tax deferred and tax free account funds are reduced in value by the amount of taxes and penalties paid.

2010 provides an opportunity for millions of new taxpayers to consider the advantages of converting IRA funds into a Roth IRA.  If you are unsure of whether this conversion would be beneficial, talk to your financial planner or tax account and ask them to help you make this determination.