Why Own Gold?
It is now easier than ever to “invest” in gold. With the advent of gold based Exchange Traded Funds that trade like stocks, an investor you can buy and sell gold as easily as buying and selling a stock. However, the fact that you can do something does not necessarily mean that you should. As with any investment, the question that must first be answered is “why should I own a position in gold.”
I often hear people say that gold is an inflation hedge. However, when one looks at the price of gold (on an inflation adjusted basis) there is little correlation between the price of gold and the annual inflation rate. In my opinion, a much better prospective on gold is that of a currency hedge.
In the past ten years, gold has increased in nominal value by 400% against the US dollar. Over that same time period, gold has increased 250% against the Euro, 190% against the Swiss Franc and “only” 150% against the Japanese yen. This demonstrates that, while gold has indeed appreciated over the past 10 years, the larger story may be the dramatic decline in the value of the US dollar over this time period.
To get more perspective on the value of gold as a surrogate for the decline of the US dollar, we compared the (inflation adjusted) value of gold over the past 40 years against the value of the Swiss Franc over that same time frame. We priced both “currencies” in US dollars. The Swiss Franc was chosen because it is (arguably) one of the most stable currencies and countries in the world.
When these two “currencies” were compared against the US dollar over the past 40 years, an interesting correlation arose. From 1971 to 1980, the dollar declined 59% against the Swiss Franc. During this same time frame, the dollar decreased 86% against the price of an ounce of gold. In the 1980s and 1990s, the value of the dollar to the Swiss Franc was reasonably stable, while the price of gold fell from its (inflation adjusted) high of $2358 to approximately $350 in 2000.
The 2000s have seen a repeat of the same easy money policy that plagued the seventies. From 2000 through 2010, the value of the dollar has declined 38% against the value of the Swiss franc and the value of the dollar has declined 73% against the price of an ounce of gold. Thus, the question for a potential gold investor is what policies are being implemented that will strengthen the dollar and cause a decline in gold prices as occurred in the 1980s.
Only time will tell if the dollar will stabilize, as it did in the 1980s, or if it will continue its decade long decline. Until concrete policies are implemented by the Fed and the Treasury to strengthen the US dollar, a small gold position might be a reasonable hedge against the possibility of the US dollar’s continued decline.


